National Security Network

President Bush's Legacy

President Bush President Bush's Legacy

President Bush

This is NSN's 11-part examination of George W. Bush's national security and foreign policy legacy.

The sorry national security legacy of the Bush administration can be measured in in the President’s failure to meet his own rhetorical objectives:  “victory” in Iraq, an Afghanistan cleansed of terrorists, a Middle East transformed and democratic, a US military strengthened, a global economy rejuvenated and a world in which democracy and freedom are “on the march.” It can also be charted in the renewal of terrorism, religious extremism and violence emanating from Central and South Asia, the Middle East, Africa and Central Asia about which the administration can or will do little; the disintegration of our closest alliances and rise of states openly hostile to us in our own hemisphere.  Perhaps most starkly it is marked in domestic and world public opinion, where President Bush plummeted from the highest – to lowest-ranked President in the history of public opinion research, and took global regard for the US to uncharted lows.  This dramatic decline, the largest in history, can be attributed first and foremost to the President’s failed national security policies.  While economic failure will undoubtedly mar the Bush’s legacy, it is his foreign policy which will define George W. Bush as one of the worst presidents in American history.

Read the full paper: A National Security Legacy of Failure »

President Bush

Rumsfeld's Recriminations

Report 9 February 2011
Yesterday, former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld released his memoir, which chronicles his years of government service. It's an 800-plus page tome entitled, "Known and Unknown." Rumsfeld tells his side of the story of the myriad disasters of the George W. Bush administration's foreign policy, most notably the Iraq war. The book dodges blame or tries to rewrite history on a number of issues -- including planning for the Iraq war, manipulating intelligence, torture of detainees and errors in post-war Iraq. Fred Kaplan of Slate says the book's "distortions and lies... are just too blatant to be countenanced." Rumsfeld's memoir represents the latest installment in a long line of former Bush administration officials who, instead of exhibiting leadership and taking the blame for their mistakes, try to shirk responsibility and point fingers.
More »
President Bush

Competing Histories

Report 9 November 2010
In 1943, Churchill was already planning his wartime memoirs.  He told Stalin and Roosevelt, "History will judge us kindly... because I shall write the history." Today, George W. Bush presented his draft of history in his memoir Decision Points.  In coming weeks moviegoers can check out two other first drafts, each casting a different light on the national security decisions of the period.  Richard Clarke's documentary S.O.S.-State of Security tells an insider's story of the failures of government in both the run-up to and aftermath of 9-11.  Director (and son of an Iran-contra prosecutor) Doug Liman's Fair Game draws a thin veil of fiction over the court transcripts retelling the stories of Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson's run-in with the Bush White House over intelligence used to make the case for the Iraq War.   
More »
President Bush

Past Bush Administration Failures in Iraq and Afghanistan Still Having Repercussions Today

Report 26 October 2009
Iraq just experienced its worst bombing in two years and today was the deadliest day in Afghanistan in four years. While conservatives want to pretend that the history of America’s involvement in these wars started only when President Obama was sworn-in to office, the reality is that the new Administration is dealing with the fallout of eight years of incompetent war time management by the past Administration. Contrary to statements by his critics, President Obama has moved aggressively to clean up previous messes made in both theaters. In Iraq, he set a timetable for the extrication of American forces, pushed Iraqis to take control of their own future, and has been intensely engaged in resolving political disputes. In Afghanistan, the President has increased our resources and manpower while focusing on developing a strategy for a war that had been without one.
More »